post_page_cover

‘City of Wind’ Review — Tradition Clashes With Modernity

Sep 24, 2023


I first encountered Lkhagvadulam Purev-Ochir’s work back in 2021 at the Sundance Film Festival. I was enchanted by the short film “Shiluus” (then titled “Mountain Cat”) about a girl in modern-day Mongolia who is brought to a local shaman by her mother. It is only when the shaman lifts his mask that we realize that the man beneath the mask is merely a boy, the same age as the girl. When they meet outside after the shaman ceremony, the two strike up a rapport that feels both flirtatious and youthful. I remember thinking back then that I would watch a full-length feature exactly about this concept. So, when I saw that Purev-Ochir had indeed turned that idea into a film called City of Wind, I felt compelled to watch it.

‘City of Wind’ Finds Balance Between Teen Drama and Meditative Narrative
Image via TIFF

As Purev-Ochir’s directorial debut, City of Wind expands on the ideas presented in “Shiluus.” At its core, the film is a coming-of-age drama focused on a Mongolian shaman, Ze (Tergel Bold-Erdene). By day, he is a high school student, soft-spoken, and frequently teased by his classmates for the fact that he works as a shaman. In his free time, he dons a ceremonial robe and mask and summons the ancestral spirit known as “Grandpa spirit” to help his community. It’s obvious that Ze has deep roots with the traditional side of his culture, even if he is also a 17-year-old who likes to spend his time on Instagram looking at his crush’s photos. He believes in what he does, it’s not a swindle or a scam for him.

Things change when one of the people who comes to see the shaman is a girl his own age, brought to him by her mother to prepare before major heart surgery. Maralaa (Nomin-Erdene Ariunbyamba) is skeptical of Ze’s shaman abilities and rebuffs him after their session, viewing him as an opportunist rather than the real deal. Still, Ze is a 17-year-old, and hormones are a real thing, so inevitably when Ze visits Maralaa in the hospital after her surgery, the two flirt and soon start dating. The sweet, puppy love between Ze and Maralaa begins to dominate his life. He goes out clubbing with her, drinks alcohol, has sex, rebels in class, and the two of them even dye their hair blonde together.

This change in lifestyle slowly separates him from his connection to the ancestral spirits. Though his time with Maralaa is seen through rose-colored lenses, when Ze is unable to call to the spirits, he feels a distinct loss of something. City of Wind often plays with the contradictions of youth and the push-and-pull between modernity and tradition. Ze wants to live in a high-rise apartment though he fully believes in his role as a shaman, while Maralaa is a total skeptic but longs to live out in the wide open, on a farm in the countryside. The film balances the idea of the two, showing us the blossoming romance without neglecting the meditative tone of the narrative.

‘City of Wind’ Leans Into Shamanism Without Judgment
Image via TIFF

While most of City of Wind is grounded in reality, which perhaps invites the audience to be skeptical of Ze’s abilities, Purev-Ochir isn’t afraid to dabble in a bit of magical realism in order to drive its ideas home. There isn’t anything wrong with partying and having fun and dying your hair, but Ze’s detachment from what he believes is severing his tie to the spiritual. Although his romance with Maralaa is genuine, the hollowness of what is considered a modern lifestyle is unfulfilling and quite literally spirit-killing. Ze’s shamanism is not painted as superfluous, at least not to the older generation he typically serves. While his classmates might mock the Grandpa spirit, for many, Ze’s connection to the spirit offers more support than any other person could.

RELATED: ‘American Fiction’ & ‘Dicks: The Musical’ Win Big at TIFF 2023 People’s Choice Awards

Purev-Ochir juxtaposes shopping malls with yurts; showing us the quiet life on the grasslands where Ze and his family live and also the darkly lit clubs of the congested city where he and Maralaa go to dance. Purev-Ochir and cinematographer Vasco Viana paint a rich and diverse visual palette, sometimes with muted pastels and sometimes with vibrant neons. As much as this story is about Ze, it is also a look into Mongolia that stretches far beyond what Western society imagines when they think of the country. It presents the truth as it is, a country that still holds onto its folk religion while also changing with the technological age.

At times City of Wind seems more interested in showing this contrast than developing Ze’s story, which is a rather simple one, but visually there is so much to enjoy about the film that the slow pacing and somewhat disjointed storytelling can be forgiven. As far as feature debuts go, Purev-Ochir delivers a solid offering, one that showcases her strengths and leans into the soul of her original short, elaborating on an intriguing concept to impressive results.

Rating: B-

The Big Picture

City of Wind is a visually stunning film that explores the tensions between modernity and tradition in Mongolia through the story of a teenage shaman. The film emphasizes the importance of spiritual connection and the emptiness of a purely materialistic lifestyle, using magical realism to drive its themes home. While the storytelling may be slow-paced and disjointed at times, City of Wind is a promising directorial debut that showcases the filmmaker’s strengths and expands on the concept explored in the original short film.

City of Wind had its North American Premiere at the 2023 Toronto International Film Festival.

Disclaimer: This story is auto-aggregated by a computer program and has not been created or edited by filmibee.
Publisher: Source link

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
The Running Man Review | Flickreel

Two of the Stephen King adaptations we’ve gotten this year have revolved around “games.” In The Long Walk, a group of young recruits must march forward until the last man is left standing. At least one person was inclined to…

Dec 15, 2025

Diane Kruger Faces a Mother’s Worst Nightmare in Paramount+’s Gripping Psychological Thriller

It's no easy feat being a mother — and the constant vigilance in anticipation of a baby's cry, the sleepless nights, and the continuous need to anticipate any potential harm before it happens can be exhausting. In Little Disasters, the…

Dec 15, 2025

It’s a Swordsman Versus a Band of Cannibals With Uneven Results

A traditional haiku is anchored around the invocation of nature's most ubiquitous objects and occurrences. Thunder, rain, rocks, waterfalls. In the short poems, the complexity of these images, typically taken for granted, are plumbed for their depth to meditate on…

Dec 13, 2025

Train Dreams Review: A Life in Fragments

Clint Bentley’s Train Dreams, adapted from Denis Johnson’s 2011 novella, is one of those rare literary-to-film transitions that feels both delicate and vast—an intimate portrait delivered on an epic historical canvas. With Bentley co-writing alongside Greg Kwedar, the film becomes…

Dec 13, 2025