Lily Collins is excited to tell you what she wants, what she really, really wants. 

And what Emily in Paris star wants was to give fans a twofer for Halloween 2024, dressing up as not only the Spice Girls‘ Emma Bunton, a.k.a. Baby Spice, but also as Victoria Beckham, a.k.a. Posh Spice.

“Started the day as Baby and ending as Posh,” Lily wrote on Instagram Oct. 31. “Spicing up my life this Halloween.”

The 35-year-old shared several snaps of her costumes, showing off her blonde pigtail wig for Baby Spice, which she paired with a Spice Girls T-shirt and jeans while giving a shushing pose for the camera. For Posh, Lily traded her blonde tresses for a short, brown bob and opted for an all-black outfit complete with a pencil skirt and blazer. Both looks echoed an iconic Spice Girls photo, which she also shared a photo of.

Lily’s fans were obviously obsessed with her dual looks, with one writing, “That’s iconic! Double the style, double the fun!”