“It’s just about not being delusional,” the Pillows and Beer podcast cohost told E!. “Just because we’re on TV doesn’t mean that we’re not going to deal with the exact same things that everyone else out there does. If we were to sit there and act like everything just works out every single time, I just think that would be dishonest. Obviously we want it to work out.”

So, yes, after almost three years of dating, the reality stars are more in love than ever.

“For us, we’re like, ‘Hey, we haven’t figured out everything yet, but we love each other and we’re happier together than we are apart,'” Craig noted. “We’re going to take every challenge as it comes instead of letting the fear of the future ruin the happiness of today.”

Plus, if the two ever do get married, Paige is a step ahead with wedding planning, especially when it comes to the menu.