Summary

Gene Roddenberry regretted firing Grace Lee Whitney from Star Trek and expressed remorse before his death in 1991. Whitney’s character, Janice Rand, was eliminated from the show due to the network’s desire for Captain Kirk to have more female friends. Rand’s character had potential for further development and had a significant impact on fans who continued to support her despite her absence from later seasons.

Gene Roddenberry boldly went where no one has gone before in television and film history. But amid all his success thanks to the Star Trek franchise, he still regretted axing one member from the sci-fi saga’s family tree. During the first season of Star Trek: The Original Series, Grace Lee Whitney portrayed the part of yeoman Janice Rand, but Whitney was fired after only appearing in eight episodes.

Before Roddenberry passed away in 1991, he expressed having felt remorse for firing Whitney. And his sentiments were later published in 2019’s The Fifty-Year Mission: The Complete, Uncensored, Unauthorized Oral History of Star Trek: The First 25 Years (per Slash Film). Roddenberry said:

“The mistake I made with Rand, and I’ve regretted it many times, was the network said to me, ‘We’ve been meeting on this, and we think what you should do is get a different, exciting young lady every week, rather than the same one.’ And I had said ‘no’ so many times to the network that I thought I maybe should give them a ‘yes’ this time. But looking back now, I would’ve kept Rand on the show and I’m sorry I didn’t. I know what a disappointment it was to Grace Lee Whitney.”

Related: The Best Original Star Trek Characters, Ranked

Gene Roddenberry Regretted Firing Grace Lee Whitney
Paramount

Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry ultimately fired actress Grace Lee Whitney and eliminated the role of yeoman Janice Rand. Whitney’s last appearance on Star Trek: The Original Series came when the episode Balance of Terror aired on December 15, 1966. And apparently the powers-that-be wanted Captain Kirk (William Shatner) to be unfettered by a single, female friendship.

Whitney said in the same book:

“I was let go because of several reasons. The main reason was that they told me they wanted Captain Kirk to have more female friends. They felt Rand and Kirk were getting too close, and they didn’t want that. They were going to write Scotty [James Doohan] out, too, but decided to keep him. They even had a clause in Leonard’s [Nimoy] contract that said if his ears didn’t go over they could get rid of him.”

Many of Rand’s scenes centered around interactions with Captain Kirk. In fact, one of Whitney’s most memorable performances came in the episode The Enemy Within. A transporter malfunction splits Kirk into two parts, which creates “good” and “evil” versions of the Enterprise’s captain.

Kirk’s animalistic nature attacks Rand, and she scratches his face to escape the captain. Throughout the episode, Whitney shows off her acting range as she calls on an array of emotions to express the yeoman’s love and disdain for her commander’s split personalities. The riveting performance truly brought Whitney’s acting talents to the forefront, as well as Rand’s mental and physical strengths.

Whitney also said:

“Rand had a lot of strength and a lot of guts. I think her character could have been further developed. Rand was on the same card of credits as McCoy [DeForest Kelley] in the beginning. She was to be the major female character. All the early publicity shots were with Bill [Shatner], Leonard [Nimoy], and me in the middle. The thing about this business is that you have to survive no matter what they do to you. Taking her out of the show has made Rand somewhat of an underdog and the fans have always rallied behind her all this time. I feel cheated.”

While Janice Rand never appeared in the second or third seasons of Star Trek: The Original Series, Whitney reprised the role of the one-time yeoman when Star Trek: The Motion Picture hit theaters in 1979. It was a small part, but she got to work alongside Shatner again — and James Doohan. Rand returned for cameos in the rest of the original crew’s feature films, with the exception of Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and Star Trek V: The Final Frontier.