“Erin was crazy about the kissing scene,” Sara told E! during the joint interview. “She was in their face the whole time off camera. She knew exactly how she wanted that kiss and she got the kiss.”

All of that attention to detail certainly paid off. After all, Nobody Wants This was nominated for three awards at this year’s Critics Choice Awards: Best Comedy Series, Best Actor in a Comedy Series (Adam) and Best Actress in a Comedy Series (Kristen). 

However, all the success still feels unexpected for Sara. As she put it, “We really didn’t know what we had.”