It’s probably not far-fetched to imagine that most people, if pressed, couldn’t tell you what cryptocurrency actually is, much less what it’s for. Future money? Fake money? Monopoly money for libertarians and marks? Ben McKenzie’s documentary “Everyone Is Lying to You For Money” is built around that fog, and around the suspicion that the fog is the point. The more people talk about crypto, the less legible the business becomes. That’s not a bug in McKenzie’s film. It’s the thesis: obscurity is the sales pitch, confusion is the product, and somewhere beneath all the techno-utopian jargon sits a very old scam in a very new hoodie.
READ MORE: 17 Must-See April Films: ‘The Drama,’ ‘The Christophers,’ ‘Mother Mary,’ ‘Normal’ and More
McKenzie, best known from “The O.C.” and “Gotham,” directs and stars, opening the movie with a knowingly fake-out walk through a rocky desert he initially presents as Mesopotamia before revealing it’s really West Texas. The gag is simple but effective. So is the larger point. This is a movie about illusion, misdirection, and people trying to pass one thing off as another. McKenzie says crypto is stupid, and the film spends the rest of its runtime arguing that it is worse than stupid: a system sustained by bad faith, magical thinking, and a steady supply of people willing to believe that jargon is the same thing as value.
The movie grows out of McKenzie’s own bad investing experience and his pandemic-era rabbit-hole descent into the crypto world, which gives the film a useful layman’s perspective. He isn’t approaching the material like a finance expert descending from on high. He approaches it like a skeptical convert who kept asking the obvious question nobody in the room seemed eager to answer: what does any of this actually do? That question takes him to crypto conferences, where the absurdity starts writing itself. In one of the film’s cleaner punchlines, crypto isn’t even accepted when he tries to buy a drink at a crypto event. That would be funny if it weren’t so revealing. A currency that can’t function as currency is not much of a revolution. It’s branding.
That same pattern repeats in McKenzie’s interviews with industry figures like Celsius founder Alex Mashinsky and FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried, both of whom were eventually exposed as massive crypto fraudsters. What the film keeps exposing in those encounters isn’t just slipperiness, but a business model built on slipperiness. McKenzie presses Mashinsky on how Celsius actually makes money and gets vagueness in return. He presses Bankman-Fried and gets more evasive, pseudo-earnest fog. The film doesn’t have to overstate what that means. If the people running these companies can’t or won’t explain, in plain language, where the value comes from, the implication is sitting right there in front of you: the machine runs on confidence tricks, circular logic, and the constant need for new money to keep old promises alive. Call it innovation if you want. McKenzie’s film keeps suggesting a ruder, more accurate word: grift.
There’s a sly advantage to McKenzie’s celebrity here. He’s recognizable enough to disarm people, or at least wrong-foot them, and the movie gets good mileage out of the contrast between Ryan Atwood asking basic questions and finance-world operators trying to talk around him. That fish-out-of-water dynamic adds humor and makes dense material more digestible. Later turns involving McKenzie’s book “Easy Money” and his Senate appearance push the story into stranger territory, but they also clarify what the film has been building toward: crypto didn’t merely attract shady characters; shadiness was baked into the enterprise from the start. The scandals are not side effects. They’re the inevitable expression of an industry that keeps promising democratized wealth while functioning like a casino crossed with a cult.
The film isn’t flawless. Some exchanges with wife Morena Baccarin feel staged, and a visit to the set of “Greenland 2” for an on-camera chat with Gerard Butler has a whiff of actorly convenience. At times, the editing makes the documentary feel a little too polished, a little too eager for narrative neatness. But those are manageable flaws. McKenzie does the homework, and, more importantly, he knows how to translate it into plain English. He has a self-deprecating ease that keeps the movie from turning into a lecture, even as its argument grows darker and more pointed.
Support independent movie journalism to keep it alive. Sign up for The Playlist Newsletter. All the content you want and, oh, right, it’s free.
What finally gives “Everyone Is Lying to You for Money” its bite is that it stops treating crypto like a mystery to be solved and starts treating it like a con to be named. By the end, the lingering question isn’t really what cryptocurrency is. McKenzie more or less answers that by process of elimination. It isn’t a stable currency, it isn’t a meaningful public good, and it certainly isn’t the clean technological future its evangelists keep pitching. What it often looks like instead is a speculative shell game, a Ponzi-adjacent ecosystem of hype, extraction, and vanishing accountability. McKenzie may frame the journey with some bemused curiosity, but the movie lands somewhere much angrier than that. Fair enough. A system this shady doesn’t deserve awe. It barely deserves the dignity of confusion [B]