Reviews 9.1/10

‘Everytime’ Review: Germany’s Oscar Submission Is Rapturously Beautiful, Achingly Sad & The Directing Achievement Of The Year

administrator Verified Critic
Nov 15, 2026 12 min read 34 Views 0

The continuous six-minute take in which the precipitating event in Sandra Wollner’s “Everytime” occurs is surely the shot of the year. Its extraordinary staging only heightens the scene’s heart-in-mouth terror. The imaginative, unorthodox construction announces early on that Wollner’s filmmaking has no intention of adhering to convention, classically beautiful though it is.

Her exploration of grief is equally heterodox. When 16-year-old Jessie (Carla Hüttermann) suddenly, unexpectedly dies, her mother, sister, and boyfriend must cope in singular, private ways. Wollner, above all, brings into sharp relief the inhuman courage society demands of mere mortals to go on after the death of a loved one, as if nothing has changed.

READ MORE: 88 Must-See Movies This Fall: ‘Dune: Part Three,’ ‘Digger,’ ‘Avengers: Doomsday,’ ‘The Adventures Of Cliff Booth’ & More

“Everytime” begins on the eve of a vacation that will never happen. Jessie sneaks out at night from the home she shares with her single mother, Ella (Birgit Minichmayr), and 10-year-old sister, Melli (Lotte Keiling), to party with her boyfriend, Lux (Tristán López). She dances through the night, takes drugs that Lux supplies, and climbs to the terrace of a high-rise to see the sunrise, before calamity strikes.

A year later, the inexorability of life and unyielding German pragmatism find Ella and Melli carrying on, their devastation buried away for another day. Reacquaintance with Lux brings them face-to-face with mourning that never happened and wounds that never healed. Lux has returned after a year in Texas, where he went perhaps to study, perhaps to escape the outcries of responsibility. Now back in Berlin, he seems as resolutely impassive as they are and already has a new girlfriend.

Before Jessie’s death, Lux was a fixture in their home, almost part of their family. But what remains to be said now? Life, more than Wollner the writer-director, keeps finding ways to throw them together. They seek each other out, too, barreling toward not a reckoning but an absolution, and the possibility of equanimity.

Melli reads and rereads her chat history with Jessie while Lux listens to the voice notes she sent him. They bond over “Vintage Story,” the “Minecraft”-like video game Jessie played, with its boxy aesthetic and square-shaped sun. Ella and Melli visit Jessie’s grave every week, and Melli decorates it with her favorite toys.

When Lux visits their home, they return the chain he had given Jessie just before she died. In a cup by her bedside, he finds a hidden, unused condom: his and Jessie’s secret. Jessie haunts the picture like a memento mori, never more so than when Melli watches camcorder home videos of Jessie as a toddler in Tenerife.

It is one thing for Ella and Lux to wear their grown-up stoicism like armor against hurt. But it is cruel to expect Melli to take life’s blows on the chin. When Ella impulsively whisks the three of them away to Spain for the vacation that never happened, Melli comes to the fore and must make sense of an unfeeling universe.

The Tenerife-set portion of “Everytime” has drawn comparisons to “Aftersun.” With good reason, as these resort-set family elegies of retrospective and prospective grief were both shot by British cinematographer Gregory Oke. Awash in summery colors like Charlotte Wells’ film, “Everytime” is even more splendiferous. The glimmering waves break like so many hearts, in a spectacle as majestic as your latest “filmed for IMAX” ticket-guzzler.

“Everytime” is not a travelogue, but don’t be surprised to find yourself looking up Tenerife tickets. As the adults leave their feelings maddeningly unexpressed even at this intimate retreat, Wollner introduces her most disquieting gambit. Nominally centered on Melli’s subjectivity, the world comes undone because something has to give.

READ MORE: ‘Aftersun’ Review: Paul Mescal Elevates A Hazy, ‘90s-Nostalgic Memory That’s All About The Vibes [Cannes]

One of Melli’s playmates shoots a flare at the setting sun, freezing it in place during the magic hour. It also turns square, like in “Vintage Story.” Most mysteriously, Jessie reappears as a toddler, now Melli’s little sister, in a role reversal. “Everytime’s” left turn is as consoling as it is disturbing, but it fits with Wollner’s vision, a metaphysical juxtaposition that resists explanation as much as it doesn’t need one.

Earlier in the film, Ella retraces Jessie’s last steps with Lux, taking the drugs she had taken. Ella instinctively stops at the same train tracks her daughter had a year ago, in a communion of future memory and past projection. In a moment out of Olivier Assayas’ “Personal Shopper,” Melli texts “Happy Birthday” to Jessie, and for a heart-stopping moment, the three dots appear as if a response is forthcoming, before she’s unceremoniously interrupted. If grief can feel like the earth will stop spinning, in “Everytime,” it does.

Far from wallowing in misery, Wollner’s filmmaking is steadfast and confident, particularly in some stunningly accomplished tableaux. The opening two-minute shot catches Ella and her children from afar as they disappear and reappear, climbing the steps of a railway station, their dialogue always audible. The aforementioned shot of the year, pulled off with a paparazzi-like telephoto lens, is a sublimely original piece of staging, with her lead actors half a mile from the camera.

Wollner takes a bludgeon to the televisual, shallow-focused, center-focused drudgery prevalent in cinema today. Another scene has Lux swimming in a canal. He’s reduced to an ant-like figure in an undulating mass of water, his state of mind expressed wordlessly, without histrionics, through mise-en-scène alone. These are cinematic images designed for the big screen, with Wollner unafraid to gaze at her characters from afar, for in cinema, the director’s gaze can also be the gaze of God.

The contemporary Berlin and Tenerife that Wollner conjures come alive through her actors’ pulsating performances. Birgit Minichmayr, first known to us through her staggering performance in Maren Ade’s “Everyone Else,” hasn’t yielded any of her screen presence or star power. Her ability to hold our gaze is as potent as ever when Wollner lingers on her face for two minutes straight in a spellbinding sequence. The façade of bravery crumbles in moments of grace, as when a fart triggers giggles that dissolve into tears.

Lotte Keiling’s exemplary child performance captures how monumental setbacks, both small and large, feel at her young age. Breaking her phone feels like a second onset of disaster, and her rage and helplessness are palpable. Some might see the last act as a drug-induced hallucination by Melli, but Keiling’s groundedness and investment argue against simplistic readings.

Hüttermann, with only 20 minutes of screen time, leaves a strong impression that haunts the rest of the film. Tristán López brings sensitivity to a young man caught between guilt, regret, and impulse.

Support independent movie journalism. Sign up for The Playlist Newsletter for the latest film and TV news, reviews, interviews, and more—free.

“Everytime” won the Prix Un Certain Regard, but its ambition and achievement mark it as more suited for the Cannes Competition, where Wollner could no doubt compete in time. With only her third film, Wollner impresses with a delicately shaded filmmaking ethos, alive to the power and beauty of images, as well as their weight and meaning. Her unsentimental humanism unveils inconceivable grief with generosity and serenity. Discerning audiences will find in “Everytime” a transporting and rewarding cinematic experience. [A]


Ankit Jhunjhunwala
+ posts

Ankit is a writer and film critic who has spent more than a decade chasing bold, provocative cinema across festivals from Cannes and Berlin to New York and Toronto. Drawn to films that take risks and break molds, he covers everything from adventurous arthouse discoveries to major releases—and is always looking for a story that does something unexpected.

Editorial Disclaimer: This story is auto-aggregated by a computer program and has not been created or edited by Filmibee.com.
Publisher: Source link
Verified Critic & Columnist

administrator

Senior Entertainment & Cinema Columnist at Filmibee. Passionate about world cinema, screenplays, box-office stats, and film aesthetics.

View all articles by this author