Back to selection
Julia Loktev Captures History as It Happens
Julia Loktev had just arrived in Moscow to follow a few journalists targeted by Putin’s regime when Russia began its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. That was February 2022, and the electrifying documentary that emerged from those tumultuous weeks—My Undesirable Friends: Part I — Last Air in Moscow (2024)—shadows a team of female reporters from Russia’s last independent television channel, TV Rain, as they pondered whether to bolt to the nearest border or risk being arrested for their work. Part II — Exile tracks the same journalists as they adjust to life abroad, having left their home country in haste. Loktev’s subjects hopscotch between places as far-flung as Georgia, Israel, Latvia, and New York City, and the director—again acting as a one-woman crew, shooting with an iPhone—tags along to chronicle their experience of limbo.
Temporally and geographically, Exile has a much larger scope than Last Air in Moscow. The first installment covered only a few months spent in and around the Russian capital, whereas the second stretches over years and continents, even as it follows the basic structure of its predecessor, divided into five chapters following the dissidents as they wrestle with their new circumstances: Anna (“Anya”) Nemzer, a talk-show host for TV Rain, adjusts to her new deracinated life with her husband and teenage daughter; Elena (“Lena”) Kostyuchenko, one of the group’s youngest, escapes war-torn Ukraine and multiple attempts on her life at the front and abroad; and Ksenia (“Ksyusha”) Mironova, briefly returns to Russia to attend the trial of her fiancé, Ivan Safronov, a fellow journalist sentenced to 22 years in prison on bogus treason charges.
Nothing haunts these reporters more than the fear that they might never get to work again—that no one back home will hear their stories or be able to steer their country away from the abyss. Wartime censorship means all conflict-related coverage is swiftly removed from the web; with their jobs and careers erased, no money, and no place to stay, Loktev’s undesirables all succumb to a strange cognitive dissonance. They have been persecuted, but at least they’re not suffering the atrocities their country is perpetrating against Ukrainians. To be a Russian dissident today, Anya muses, is to “feel like it’s 1941, and you’re simultaneously the Germans and the Jews”.
That paradox makes for some rich material, which Loktev spends the film’s six hours mining. Much of Exile tracks Anya and her colleagues as they navigate their identities in countries that regard them as suspicious outcasts. And Loktev makes something thrilling out of ostensibly static material; there’s real urgency to her interviews, and an edge-of-the-seat tension to the relentless efforts of the TV Rain crew to set up camp overseas and keep giving voice to Putin’s barbarities, all threats be damned. When Last Air in Moscow first reached the US, critics were quick to read it as a timely reminder that fascism can take root anywhere—the film’s lessons about Putin’s Russia eloquently spoke to Trump’s America, too. Exile arrives four years after the start of the war on Ukraine, and halfway through Trump’s second catastrophic term; the overarching question is no longer whether fascism can be avoided, but how—now that it’s here—one can still speak truth to power.

LEONARDO GOI: Part of what makes Exile so exhilarating is the feeling that you’re watching life captured in real time. Yours is the rare film that doesn’t just document but seems to be reacting to the tumultuous events around you. It made me wonder about your writing process: whether you had a list of topics your subjects would want to talk about, or that you wanted to touch on. To what extent was any of this “written”?
JULIA LOKTEV: Oh, not much—shit just happened! [Laughs.] I began with one idea, and then things took off and history started to unfold; I had to rush to keep up. [Last Air in Moscow] kicked off with a few Russian journalists who had been named foreign agents. I thought it was interesting. Plus, it had just started happening. I flew to Russia and began to film. I thought, Okay, this is going to be about these people trying to figure out how to live with what seemed to be just snowballing levels of repression. But then the full-scale war broke out, and every single person I was filming had to flee Russia within a week; they were going from country to country, and I was just keeping up with them. What I did really well—if I can compliment myself on this—was casting. I chose people immediately. Some of the initial casting was done by the so-called Russian Ministry of Justice: we were choosing young women whom authorities had named foreign agents, and others we thought were going to be named next.

LG: Exile is a lot more sprawling than Last Air in Moscow; here too, you split the chronicle into different chapters. Some of these are basically built around one incident, so it’s easy to see your rationale there, but in others, the connective thread feels more elusive. Could you speak more about these attempts to editorialize such vast material?
JL: The film is linear, chronologically speaking, so the question was: where and how do you divide time? The first two chapters track the days and months immediately after they fled their country; time works differently then. As one of the characters says, “Two days ago, I had a job, a home, a boyfriend. I knew who I was, and now I’m a loser in Istanbul.”
Putin refers to these journalists as the flies that Russia spat out of its mouth, and here they are, trying to figure things out from scratch. How do we get our TV channel back up and running? How do we start reporting as soon as possible? Our country is waging this horrific war that we feel it’s our duty to report on, but we don’t have an apartment, our bank cards don’t work, and we don’t know where we’re going. But we have to work. They figure things out in the initial months, and then time gradually slows down. The last chapter covers a much longer period—a year and a half or so—where time effectively becomes suspended. It’s the long haul.
The plot in Last Air in Moscow was fairly simple: you have these journalists fighting to tell the truth until their country starts a war and they have to leave. Exile is much more complicated. In a way, it’s a film full of different plots and different challenges. The other day, I read someone making a parallel between the film and the Odyssey. And it’s true: Exile is about people who are indefinitely trying to go home, and along the way, lots of things happen. You don’t have Scylla or Charybdis, but there are constant challenges, and people are threatened, poisoned, their companies evicted—it’s an ongoing process with no end in sight, which I find so fascinating.

LG: On that note, I was hoping to hear more about your approach to editing. How much did you know about the film before you entered the cutting room, and how much of it did you discover as you cut?
JL: Obviously you know some stuff, but the goal for me is always to go into the editing like I don’t know. That’s true for both my fiction and nonfiction work. I had this transformative story when I shot Moment of Impact [1998]. It was my first film, a documentary, and I had recorded what I thought was a tremendous amount of footage, forty hours—now I know it’s nothing. But I wasn’t sure how to edit it. My advisors at film school were like, “Write out a scenario, a script, or whatever…” But that didn’t sound right. So I went to see Frederick Wiseman speak—he was doing a retrospective. It must have been the one time in my life I asked a question at a Q&A. I raised my hand and went, “How do you edit?” And he said something that transformed my life as a filmmaker. “I spend a lot of time just editing each scene unto itself—studying it, reducing it, distilling it—until I figure out what order it goes in.” And that to me made so much more sense than pretending you know. I don’t want to do that; I want to let the footage tell me what it is. Sometimes you think you know the core of a scene, but as you watch it, you start noticing nuances somewhere else. I don’t think I’ve ever looked at notes from set of the takes I thought were good. I’m like, You have the footage. Just watch it. Watch it and see where the truth is, where the juicy moments are, where the detail you might not have noticed is.

LG: You shot both Last Air in Moscow and Exile on an iPhone; I’d love to know more about the reasoning behind the choice. Leaving aside the more logistical aspects—the phone’s lighter, easier to handle—was there anything about the footage’s aesthetic that made you settle on that specific device?
JL: To tell you the truth, the choice was made in about two seconds. I flew over to Moscow the day after I got my visa, and originally planned to have someone else shoot the film. Again, I had all these assumptions in my head about what you need to make a movie, so I’d reached out to a cinematographer… But Anya [Nemzer] had invited a group of people for dinner one night and said, “Well, we don’t want this other guy to come over because we don’t really know him. We know you. You’re our friend. Can’t you shoot it?” So I borrowed his camera. He had some focus settings that I could not figure out, and people around me at the table were saying really interesting stuff. So I put the camera on the kitchen counter and picked up my phone and started shooting. And I never looked back—it was so much easier to be with people that way. We’re so used to a phone being around. Sound is very important, and luckily, Anya’s husband is a podcaster; I borrowed his microphones. I was like, “Here we go. We’re going to put some mics on the table…” It was just so easy to be present with a phone around everyone. I mean, obviously people notice it, but it’s different than having this larger object. Though I got a little 58-millimeter lens to attach to it, eventually. But I didn’t use a cage because that felt too big.
It’s still a fairly small object, even with its little fuzzy microphone, and you’re still present physically. But you also don’t have the luxury a lot of filmmakers have when they’re shooting documentary: they’ll use a long lens and stand across the room, far away, to not put themselves physically in the situation. That way, you have the illusion of a close-up. I was as close to these people as you would be to your friends when you’re hanging out—three feet or less. You’re sitting with others, you’re in the midst of it; they get used to your body, your presence. And they act differently than they would if they knew they were being watched across the room with a long lens. You don’t feel like you’re under a microscope—you’re just there with someone.
I think the film’s aesthetic is very hard to separate from the sociological or psychological aspects—how we respond to the camera. Frankly, I’ve had cinematographers look at it and say at the end, “Oh my God, that was shot on an iPhone? I had no idea!” Quality-wise, if you’re looking at it technically, especially how it responds at night, the footage is beautiful. That’s Apple, not me. It responds well to very dark spaces—you can work with very little light.

LG: But it also makes for an interesting friction, one that I think is both aesthetic and thematic, between the intimate, domestic quality of the iPhone footage and the much bigger systemic forces that are grinding these people into dust.
JL: That’s a great observation. But I think that’s more about what I’m interested in: people, their lives. And where do we live our lives? In the kitchen, at work, on the way from home to work. I am interested in the way historic events affect our lives on an everyday level rather than on this more abstract news level, which is what the journalists are reporting on. “Here is the larger story”—right, but how does it touch their lives? People fall in and out of love, they have friendships, they fall apart, they get themselves back together. That is the stuff that interests me. And it probably doesn’t have much to do with the iPhone. Even if I was filming it with a large camera, I’d still be hanging out in the kitchen.
LG: Something I found astonishing about these journalists is their commitment to treating Putin’s Russia as their country still. If the man is in power, it is their fault too—whether they voted for him or not, they’ve all, in various degrees, contributed to the way things are today. And it’s interesting to compare that stance to the readiness with which we like to distance ourselves from our own corrupt leaders: not my president.
JL: I think you’ve just nailed it. Here in the US, we’re so used to disassociating. Most people aren’t waking up saying, “My country is doing really horrible things right now.” But it is. These people, on the other hand, they don’t wash their hands of it, and I find that incredible. When they say my country, or our army, what they mean is: we are accountable, too. This conflict, these war crimes, they’re all theoretically being committed in our names. It’s too easy to say, “Well, no, I didn’t vote for him,” or, “I didn’t choose this.” These journalists know they bear responsibility for what happened. And they’re wondering what they should do, what their duty is. They know they’re not overthrowing Putin tomorrow. “Everything that isn’t killing him feels futile,” one of them says at some point, and they all struggle with this knowledge. What can you do? How do you convey to people in Russia the horrific things their country continues to do? How do you not give up or lose attention? This past year was the deadliest in Ukraine since the first year of the full-scale war, but it’s no longer in the headlines. It’s like we got used to it—that’s just how things are, and we stopped paying attention. That’s terrifying, because the war is no less horrific today than it was four years ago. So they keep trying to report on it, attract an audience, do what they can. It all circles back to what we were talking about earlier: how can one keep working—how can one do what needs to be done. I find that to be an incredible reminder, not just as a filmmaker, but as a citizen, too: do the right thing, or the best you can, to find meaning in the face of such horrors.
Publisher: Source link